Over on CGP, Joe Bihlmeyer
inquires about the strength of GINS as a leave, and Paul Sidorsky
responds:
Ah yes, that's a common trap. G is for Garbage. Dump it at the
earliest opportunity, unless you can score well and there are lots of
hooks and the bag isn't consonant heavy. Generally speaking, never keep the G as part of a fish or exchange unless you need a bingo to win and you have multiple spots to hook it.
If you hit a playable bingo it's great, but as Joe implies, if you miss your bingo the G seriously inhibits your ability to score and balance your rack. Even with the IN.I very much disagree. -ING is generally a very good combination. On an opening exchange, [GIN] outperforms IN by a wide margin. [GINS], [GEINS], and [AGINS] are also dominant leaves on an opening exchange (meaning that they clearly outperform any of their subsets), as is true of many other well-balanced leaves containing ING.
It's true that G has terrible synergy with most scoring consonants, but this very fact is substantially offset by ING leaves, both because of the bingos they form with many tiles and because, being longer leaves, they are less likely to draw such tiles (especially two or more).
Paul's claim that "the G seriously inhibits your ability to score and balance your rack" is particularly confusing. Yes, this is true of the G more generally, but the good ING leaves are
already well-balanced. They have slightly more consonants than vowels, no duplicates, and no awful synergies. And they are longish, which is better as a rule. Only a few combinations are both bingo-prone and lead reliably to nice intermediate plays, like CEH, but e.g. even CEGHIN and CGHIN are often better than CEHIN.
Naturally, if you're saving a very bingo-prone rack, you should consider the nature of the bingo lines. Does the board have lots of 8 lines, 2x2s, decent 9 spots? Or does it have mostly 7 lines ending in a tile other than G or starting in a vowel? Some boards will substantially reduce the value of [GIN] or [GINS]; others will enhance them. On balance, though, they are strong leaves.
Finally, for an aspiring novice who isn't yet confident about enough bingos, I'd absolutely suggest valuing ING leaves, with the caveats a) that they don't sacrifice too many points on the present turn, b) that when they fail to draw an obvious -ING bingo, they at least take the time to look for other bingos, and c) that, more generally, they don't get locked into a mindset where there is only one way to play the rack.
Current Music: Over the Rhine, "The Darkest Night of the Year"